← All stops

Shumway Farms

Afton, WY • ★ 4.9 (345 Google reviews)

Inside Shumway Farms
Shumway Farms photo from Google
Shumway Farms photo from Google

The Story

The warm glow from Shumway Farms welcomed us like an old friend, a perfect parlor stop nestled in the Wyoming valley. Inside, the air hummed with happy chatter and the sweet scent of classic, homemade delights promised a real treat. Every scoop and bite tasted like a simpler time, a comforting slice of Americana to savor on our journey.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Sarah Rowe

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    WOW. We are so glad we saw the sign for Shumway Farms while driving from Flaming Gorge to Teton Valley. We stopped in on a whim and were thrilled to find so much fresh dairy at such reasonable prices. We bought two containers of yogurt, a half gallon of raw milk, butter, and ice cream for our family of five for around $30, which honestly felt incredible for the quality. Everything tasted fresh and delicious, and you can tell this is a place people in the area truly value. Highly recommend stopping if you’re passing through.

  • Dawnie

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    This place never disappoints. Their SKYR yogurt is so good (lemon and maple are my absolute favorites). The creaminess and flavor make it hard to not eat a whole container in one sitting. Also enjoyed the ice cream. Ate 2 other pints before I thought to take a photo. It is a must stop anytime we are in the area.

  • Damien

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Ice cream was amazing. Luckily we got there at a non-busy time so we were able to park our fifth-wheel camper in the parking lot. A nice little playground in the middle of the parking lot loop. Several beautiful original paintings are for sale inside too. And you could see cows.

  • Josh Williams

    ★ 5 • a year ago

    This ice cream is AMAZING! We stopped here on our trek from Rock Springs, WY to Jackson, WY. It was the perfect way to top off the picnic lunch we had at Fossil Butte National Monument. We were there during the "off season" and the store was self-service / self checkout with only pints and quarts for sale (no scooping) - but no complaints at all. There were even baby cows out front!