Sisters of Anarchy Ice Cream
Shelburne, VT • ★ 4.8 (143 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Sisters of Anarchy felt like a sweet trip back in time, with vibrant retro colors and a happy buzz filling the air. Each generous scoop of their incredible ice cream, handcrafted with care, tasted like a little piece of Shelburne sunshine. It’s the kind of place where laughter lingers and every bite brings a smile, a true local gem.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Elizabeth Kirwan
★ 5 • 8 months ago
I have to say I have a new all time favorite ice cream shop!! It’s a little off the beaten path and so worth it. Stumbled on this gem on our way from Boston to Canada. Staff were so nice and stayed open until we got there! Clearly they are popular with the locals because several stopped for their pies too! Now the ice cream itself was incredible. The texture was perfect and the sweetness was spot on. Not over powering or fake. The flavors are fresh and natural. They really nailed everything!
Craig Gresham
★ 5 • 3 weeks ago
Delicious! Unique flavors hidden in a nondescript building. Anarchy.
Fred Nelson
★ 5 • 7 months ago
Sisters of Anarchy is a quintessential Vermont product- truly locally produced, totally unique, and full of flavor, personality, and authenticity. It is some of the most diverse and delicious ice cream that one is likely to find anywhere. Flavors like maple (Tap That), blackberry (Berry in Black), blueberry (Crystal Blue Persuasion), and various others made from farm-grown yellow raspberries, aronia berries, and a range of other fruits are truly outstanding (as well as more conventional flavors like chocolate chip (Officer Bob Special). They added pies last year, and their blackberry pie (with ginger for a distinct citrus-y zest) is world-class- again, as good a pie as one can find anywhere. This is a must-visit place for anyone traveling to the Burlington area.
Pumpernickel
★ 5 • 5 years ago
For $5 for a single scoop, this ice cream better be amazing... and it is! Generous scoops of the best ice cream you’ve ever had will convince you they should be charging $20 for a spoonful! With a wide range of flavors for those more adventurous (“The Experience” and Snap) to those who want to stick close to the classics (Plain Jane and Chocolate Safe Space), Sisters of Anarchy delivers across the board! We’ve yet to try anything that wasn’t deviously delicious! And we really love the specials that are always new to the menu! Served up in a beautiful location and with spectacular service if you can’t quite decide which scoop to commit to, this should be every Vermonter’s Summer go-to!
