Stalder Family Creamery
New Martinsville, WV • 4.9 (109 Google reviews)
The Story
The cheerful hum of friendly chatter fills the air at Stalder Family Creamery, a delightful step back in time. Sunlight spills through the windows, illuminating classic red stools and the promise of sweet indulgence. Every scoop and swirl of their creamy treats tastes like a perfect West Virginia summer day.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Nathan Hilton
• 3 months ago
I cannot express enough how great of an experience my family and I had. Coming in from out of state, we dropped by after having Pizza at Barrista’s. I ordered the banana split, which has three very generous portions of ice cream, 3 toppings, and whip cream for a reasonable price. The servers were respectful, patient, and carried smiles the whole time. The quality of the ice cream was superb, with every bite being just as good as the last, and I struggled to eat every last bite of the ice cream mountain. It was so good that my party came back the very next day and my partner and I split the same item! This creamery will forever be a positive memory of my trip to West Virginia, and if I ever do return, expect to find me here.
Nikki
• 4 months ago
This is the ten dollar turkey cheddar bacon sandwich. No bacon on it and literally one piece of meat folded in half. The price for this being ten dollars is insane. I feel like I got ripped off.
Jeffrey Blatt
• 3 months ago
I am originally from the area and come with my family twice a year. We always make a stop at Stadler Family Creamery. This is hands down the best Ice Cream in the area and the owner and staff are very friendly. Always a great time!
Savannah Perry
• 3 years ago
Love this family owned ice cream shop! They have a wonderful menu selection though on this trip we just got basic cones. Their homemade ice cream is easily one of the best I have ever had, it’s so creamy and had such a great flavor. I personally got the cherry nut which was amazing and had large pieces of fresh cherry. The shop it’s very nice and clean. Love that it is family owned and operated. The staff was very friendly, helpful and knowledgeable with the menu. We will be stopping here any time we are in the area, and I highly recommend it to anyone else.