Sugar Hill Creamery
New York, NY • 4.6 (976 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Sugar Hill Creamery, the air hums with sweet anticipation, a true retro parlor embrace. Each scoop of their unique flavors feels like a hug, crafted with the warmth only a family's touch can bring. It's a delightful haven where the spirit of old-fashioned treats sweetens every New York afternoon.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Marsha
• 4 months ago
Came here after having a midnight ice cream craving and they definitely fulfilled the craving!! Im usually not a fan of ice cream made with eggs but you cant smell or taste the eggs in theirs like the other brands of ice cream. I wish they had more assortments without the eggs like the Soursop one (which is amazing). Other than that i had a great experience here. Hopefully they come to mott haven soon!
Nikita Wright Harding
• a month ago
This was a true find. The flavors are a true work of art! We had the Peach Cobbler, Lolly’s Butter Cake; Green Carts and OH MY GOODNESS!!! The Green Carts is DEFINITELY a MUST!!!!
Mady Opouma
• 2 months ago
I was having a hard day when I came across this ice cream shop while walking home. The flavors sounded so good that I had to sample nearly all of them, and every single one was delicious. I ended up getting two scoops: Cookie & Caramel and Coffee. They’re not flavors I usually go for, but they were so good that I’m still thinking about them. Thank you for brightening my day!
Gabriel
• 7 months ago
I went to Harlem on a foodie tour and I was looking for a dessert place and found this spot. Very good ice cream. Atmosphere and service were very good.