← All stops

Sugar Hill Creamery

New York, NY • ★ 4.6 (965 Google reviews)

Inside Sugar Hill Creamery
Sugar Hill Creamery photo from Google
Sugar Hill Creamery photo from Google

The Story

Stepping into Sugar Hill Creamery, the air hums with sweet anticipation, a true retro parlor embrace. Each scoop of their unique flavors feels like a hug, crafted with the warmth only a family's touch can bring. It's a delightful haven where the spirit of old-fashioned treats sweetens every New York afternoon.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Mady Opouma

    ★ 5 • 4 weeks ago

    I was having a hard day when I came across this ice cream shop while walking home. The flavors sounded so good that I had to sample nearly all of them, and every single one was delicious. I ended up getting two scoops: Cookie & Caramel and Coffee. They’re not flavors I usually go for, but they were so good that I’m still thinking about them. Thank you for brightening my day!

  • Marsha

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    Came here after having a midnight ice cream craving and they definitely fulfilled the craving!! Im usually not a fan of ice cream made with eggs but you cant smell or taste the eggs in theirs like the other brands of ice cream. I wish they had more assortments without the eggs like the Soursop one (which is amazing). Other than that i had a great experience here. Hopefully they come to mott haven soon!

  • Angela Montero

    ★ 5 • 5 months ago

    It was my first time ordering from Sugar Hill Ice Cream for delivery, and I was pleasantly surprised 🤍🍦 Everything arrived perfectly frozen and beautifully packed, and the flavors were so rich and nostalgic. It turned an ordinary evening into something sweet and comforting. Such a lovely first experience. I’ll definitely be ordering again. ✨

  • Malik Henry

    ★ 5 • 3 weeks ago

    I am originally from NYC and was taking an evening stroll through Harlem, which caused me to stumble upon Sugar Hill Creamery, and I am so glad that I did. The ice cream is DELICIOUS and everyone that works there is so warm and welcoming. I hardly ever write reviews, but my terrific experience today led me right to Google. I’ll 100% be back during the remaining warm summer days.