Super Secret Ice Cream
Bethlehem, NH • 4.8 (850 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Super Secret Ice Cream felt like a sweet trip back in time, all checkerboard floors and happy, whispered secrets. The creamy, cold scoops were pure New England bliss, each bite a perfect echo of simpler days. It’s the kind of cozy spot where every smile feels genuine and every treat brings a little extra sunshine to Main Street.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Bryan Doyon
• a month ago
Excellent ice cream with quality and fresh ingredients. There are delicious and unique flavors and the best way to go is the six scoop sampler to try as many as you can. Lines can get long on warm days but it moves along quickly. Prices are reasonable given the quality. This is well worth the drive and a great stop in the area.
Kim
• 4 months ago
Not-so-super-secret, but they truly do have incredible ice cream. Wonderful texture, not icy, and the flavors are never artifical-tasting or overpowering. They make some fun creative flavors, but truthfully my favorites have been the simpler, classic ones - vanilla bean creme fraiche, single origin chocolate, Mount Cabot Maple, and Trillium coffee. I haven't tried the non-dairy options, but they do always have at least one on their rotating menu. The homemade waffle cones/bowls/chips are delicious as well. Plenty of seating, both in and outdoors. The staff are always so friendly, and I love that they source so many of their ingredients locally and ethically. Definitely worth the detour if you're anywhere near Bethlehem.
Thoughtful Reviewer
• 3 months ago
Off the town center you will find a great ice cream store with unique sounding names but amazing flavors with creative blends. Perfect place to complement a good dinner in town. Grab a quart to go if you want to enjoy later.
Chef Matt
• 3 months ago
My first introduction to Super Secret Ice Cream was via a request from a client for a private dinner. They were adamant on utilizing this Maine blueberry cobbler ice cream for a dessert for a five course tasting menu. It was incredible ice cream and I’ve thought about it and (almost unfairly) compared every ice cream to it since. Needless to say, I’ve been wanting to make my way up to SSIC for years now, and finally got the chance. To say my expectations were blown out of the water would be an understatement. Knowing that they have received not one, not two, but three James beard nominations for a small ice cream shop in the middle of the mountains, I was beyond excited to try them. Every flavor we tried (we went more than once while up there) was so flavorful and texturally perfect. Everything was put together so thoughtfully, from the ingredients, down to the decor. I could not recommend them enough. It’s about a two hour drive for me, but I will 100% be back. My two daughter were instantly hooked! It’s the best ice cream I have ever had and I don’t foresee that ever changing. So much respect for them and what they’re doing!