← All stops

The City Creamery

West Yellowstone, MT • ★ 4.4 (331 Google reviews)

Inside The City Creamery
The City Creamery photo from Google
The City Creamery photo from Google

The Story

Stepping into The City Creamery feels like a sweet trip back in time, with its cozy retro charm and cheerful hum. The scent of waffle cones and creamy delights fills the air, promising a treat for every palate. Each scoop of ice cream is a little taste of classic American joy, perfect for a sunny afternoon in West Yellowstone.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Geeky Girl Adventures

    ★ 5 • a week ago

    Just down the street from where we ate dinner - they recommended heading here for dessert. It is an outside booth type thing with an area next to it to sit under umbrellas if you wanted. We were both SO glad that we did we checked out the place. I had the Chocolate/Orange and my partner had the Huckleberry. Great ice cream and quite a large scoop! Stop here - totally worth it!

  • Aon

    ★ 2 • 8 months ago

    This was a pretty disappointing ice cream. The texture was icy instead of creamy. The flavor was off, too. The service was good, though.

  • James Schindler

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Very friendly. Amazing caramel cookie crunch and the best strawberry ice cream ever. A must try if you visit.

  • Julie inminneapolis

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    The best ice cream on the stretch of Main Street in West Yellowstone. The double chocolate orange and Huckleberry flavors are particularly awesome. Home made. So delicious. Very friendly. They sell quarts if you’re local. Well worth the money!!!!