← All stops

The Creme Stop

McAlisterville, PA • 4.7 (324 Google reviews)

Inside The Creme Stop
The Creme Stop photo from Google
The Creme Stop photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Karen McLaughlin

    • 3 months ago

    My first time here...I'm from MA...my friend and I each got a medium size ice cream and it was humongous! Delicious too! And the total price for both was only $6 and change...unheard of, especially where we're from! So glad we stopped here 🙌 😊

  • Michael Szostek

    • a year ago

    We've been living up the road for under a year now. I just decided to stop by for a quick dinner while out running around. I got a cheesesteak with extra meat because I know they don't really put that much on to begin with. I added a photo of the sandwich to show you that there still wasn't enough meat on it. Also, having family who came from Philly, absolutely nobody out here in Juniata County knows how to even making an authentic cheesesteak. I wish I could teach them. My wife also ordered a shrimp basket and got a popcorn chicken basket instead. We got charged for chicken, but the popcorn chicken is almost the size of my dogs kibble and it looked like someone threw a bunch of crumbs in the box with the fries. I also wish, for them being around for so long, that they would make their own hard ice cream. It's really just a soft serve place. The ice cream is good, but it's nothing really special.

  • Eric Hershberger

    • 7 months ago

    This is the Best place for ice cream for 150 miles! Super value! Great prices and portions! My family drives 30min out of the way just to stop here! Follow them on Facebook for weekly specials and flavors! Local tip: Park in a semi circle around the store front. Get out and order at the 2 windows and go back and sit in your car until your number is called. They do have picnic tables outdoors for seating. If you like sundaes and banana slits this is your new favorite stop!!!

  • A.G.

    • a year ago

    A convenient stopping place along Rt 35 for an ice cream treat or a whole meal. Service was swift and the peanut butter fluff sundae was delicious.