The Scoop Soda Shoppe
Amityville • ★ 4.9 (55 Google reviews)
The Story
The Scoop leans hard into the soda-shoppe look — checker floor, chrome stools, neon — and then piles on shakes that would horrify a 1950s jerk in the best possible way. The egg cream, though, is old-school correct.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Anna
★ 5
What a hidden gem on a side street in Amytiville. I would not know anything about it if me and the kids didn’t decide to try something new in the area. Delicious ice cream. Plenty of fun desserts. There are no real sitting to sit and enjoy the ice cream, just an outdoor bench but it’s mostly the same exact set up at all of these ice cream shops. Anyway, highly recommend!
Danielle De Leon
★ 5
I came across this local ice cream shop to take my kids to and it did not disappoint! Amanda was so sweet and welcoming. We got the Dubai strawberry cup, Biscoff ice cream and chocolate. This adorable shop has a cute mom and pop feel to it, they even have court yard seating in the back to enjoy with your family. Ps. Don’t forget to try the cool buzzer game I was lucky enough to win on the first try 😭
Danielle Adames
★ 5
This is the cutest little ice cream shop! My cousin and I found it when we were recently walking through the village. It's located centrally in Amityville Village and has a old time feel to it. The server was very sweet to us and even gave me a sample of the ice cream when I couldn't decide which I wanted. I was torn between the Baileys ice cream and the cinnamon ice cream and she recommended the cinnamon flavor. I was so glad she did because it was delicious and even my mom who doesn't care for sweets agreed. The shop also has plenty of toppings so I decided to top my scoop off with pretzels. I highly recommend that combo to everyone! My cousin was also very happy with her birthday cake flavor! But definitely stop in and try this local shop out. You will not regret it.