Thurgood Creamery
Syracuse, UT • 4.8 (1178 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Thurgood Creamery felt like a sweet trip back in time, with its cozy retro charm and friendly, welcoming air. The creamy, handcrafted scoops tasted like pure sunshine on a warm afternoon, a perfect simple pleasure. It’s the kind of place where every visit leaves you with a smile and a longing for another delightful treat.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Christina Lainberger
• 2 months ago
I got Cookie Monster and teen got honey 🍯 macadamia nut 🌰 one, I believe mixed with something else I can’t remember. The creamy texture of the ice cream 🍨 is great and a welcome break from driving as they had plenty of seating when visited for you to sit though one scoop and make sure it’s still enough for the road or one more worthy. See you in future adventures though town.
Greyhound Mom Pam Shane
• a month ago
Delicious rich artisan ice cream. I'm obsessed with honey lavender. Friendly staff and you can sample anything you are interested in trying. Wonderful experience and a great value for the quality and quantity you receive. . I read a prior review were someone complained their ice cream tasted oily. It's not oily. Its premium higher milk fat ice cream. It's different and so much better than cheap ice cream from the store. It's the result of churning premium cream. Superior in every way and an amazing treat compared to most ice cream shops. Oh and I'm not mormon and received excellent service and the same oversized portion and attention as others in the store. Go try Thurgood. Their ice cream and staff will make your day.
Chirelle Pearson
• 9 months ago
I tried Thurgood Creamery recently with some friends. The overall consensus was not great. I didn’t mind my ice cream, I ordered the pistachio ice cream. I thought it tasted good with a fair amount of actual pistachios in the ice cream. Two people in our group ordered the cookies and cream ice cream. They did not like it at all. Said it tasted oily to them. Another friend in our group ordered the cookie monster & said it also tasted oily. They had a lot of different flavors. I’m not sure what the chance of two different ice creams both tasting oily was. Our group said they wouldn’t be back overall. The line was really long when we got there but I felt like it went quickly. Seemed like a very popular place. I thought the prices vs portions were just okay. If you go, I would suggest the pistachio ice cream personally. It was decorated cute & seemed like a fun hangout kind of place.
DP Utah
• 4 months ago
Hands down, some of the best customer service we have been shown in a while. I don’t know what training you give your staff, but it shows in a warm-hearted and kind way. Nothing over the top, but well prepared and thoughtful as we were greeted, educated on the menu of choices (I have food restrictions), and how you treated our children too. Thank you for a wonderful, low-key experience. We will certainly come back.