West Orange Creamery and Soda Fountain

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

• Emily Santistevan

  ★ 5

  Cute old fashioned soda shop. They have great homemade sodas, ice cream floats, fresh made waffle cones and bowls, many flavors of ice cream and amazing shakes. The service was kind and fast!

• Xi Li

  ★ 4

  Standard, old-school ice cream shop. Offers kiddie + small - large ice cream sizes. I liked the range of flavors, but wished the seasonal flavors were a little more interesting (since they’re limited editions). Currently, they have a pumpkin flavor, but no special flair — just regular pumpkin. I removed a star since the flavor range is very basic, similar to what I’d get at a grocery store and the limited edition flavor wasn’t even particularly special. I was a little disappointed. Trying something different is why I’d go to a locally-owned or small business run ice cream shop vs get ice cream at Publix or wherever. It’s cool that they offer wine and ice cream pints to go.

• Megan Schmidt

  ★ 4

  This place is really neat and “adult” friendly. It’s got the old school feel with a twist. You can add booze to your ice cream, such as kaluha, vodka and a few other options.They sell booze pops, too. The ice cream was good and it pretty reasonably priced for what you get. Lots of flavors, friendly staff, plenty of seating options, and wasn’t too crowded when we went. I would check it out!